Under public-only consultant contracts, private maternity care is being phased out of public hospitals. After a June standoff, the Rotunda Hospital backed down when Health Minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill threatened its funding. Emails released to The Journal on Oct. 1, 2026 show a flood of anger from women, many Fine Gael voters, saying they are losing choice in childbirth. A campaign group, Our Maternity Choice, has gathered nearly 8,000 petition signatures for an exception for maternity care. A case for "Complete the phase-out" is that public hospitals and publicly paid consultants should treat patients by need, not by ability to pay. Sláintecare means one standard of maternity care for everyone. A case for "Allow private maternity care" is that there is no private maternity hospital in Ireland, so banning private care in public hospitals removes women's choice. Continuity of consultant care matters in childbirth. Sources: The Journal, Oct. 1, 2026, https://www.thejournal.ie/private-maternity-care-letters-to-health-minister-7175627-Oct2026/ . Checked Oct. 6, 2026.

Image: AI-generated
Anonymous group breakdowns. Small groups are hidden.
Add your perspective to this topic…
The Living Topics
Arguments are recorded on your account. Sign in to add a perspective and reply to others.